How the sneaker authentication scores work
How this guide works. Scores out of 10 from five facts each company publishes, each linked and dated. Rules: How scores work. Errors: fix a listing.
Each service is scored out of 100 on five facts it publishes, and the score is shown out of 10. Since Nov 16, 2026 price carries 75 of the 100 points; the weights are price 75, speed 10, certificate 7.5, verdict transparency 5 and brand count 2.5. On these weights CheckCheck comes first with 9.9 out of 10, LegitApp second with 9.8 and LegitGrails third with 9.7.
Every rule is below, with each service’s points, so you can redo the sums yourself.
The five criteria and their weights
| Criterion | Of 100 | Of 10 | How the points are worked out |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | 75 | 7.5 | The price you pay for one pair, in US dollars, from the same option as the speed beside it. With no published price, this criterion is zero. Otherwise the cheapest option in the table gets all 75 points, the dearest gets zero, and every price in between falls on a straight line. |
| Speed | 10 | 1 | The turnaround published for the price scored. With no published turnaround, this criterion is zero. Otherwise the fastest option in the table gets all 10 points, the slowest gets zero, straight line between. |
| Certificate | 7.5 | 0.75 | A certificate issued with every check at no separate fee gets 7.5. One sold as a paid add-on gets 3.5. No certificate, or nothing published about one, gets 0. |
| Verdict transparency | 5 | 0.5 | Three statements about how a verdict is reached, 1.67 (5 ÷ 3) points for each one the company publishes in its own words and this guide prints beside it, 5 at most. |
| Brand count | 2.5 | 0.25 | 2.5 × the company’s brand count ÷ the largest count in the table. With no published count, this criterion is zero. |
| Total | 100 | 10 | The score shown is the 100-point total divided by ten. |
The scale
Each service can earn up to 100 points across 5 criteria. The score on every page is that total divided by ten, to one decimal: CheckCheck’s 98.88 points show as 9.9 out of 10. Where two services show the same figure, the exact total decides the order.
A score is arithmetic on what each company publishes about itself. Nothing here was measured or audited, so it says nothing about how accurately a service authenticates a pair.
Who is scored and who is only listed
A service is scored when it takes new customers and publishes a price for an online, photo-based check of one pair. Every other programme is listed with its facts and the reason, and never ranked.
- Entrupy, listed and not scored: Sells its app-based footwear check only on subscription to established reseller businesses, and guarantees accuracy only for new pairs; an individual cannot buy a check of sneakers they own. Listed and not scored.
- StockX Verified, listed and not scored: Verifies sneakers only as part of an order on its own marketplace, and its paid verification is an add-on to a Listings Marketplace purchase with no published price; no page read offers a check of a pair the customer already owns. Listed and not scored.
- GOAT, listed and not scored: Verifies sneakers only as they pass through a sale on its own platform, shipped to GOAT by the seller; no page read offers a check of a pair the customer already owns. Listed and not scored.
- eBay Authenticity Guarantee, listed and not scored: Authenticates only eligible sneakers bought on eBay.com, free and in hand at an authentication center after the sale; it offers no photo-based check of a pair the customer already owns. Listed and not scored.
Which price and speed count
Every price and speed a company publishes for shoes counts, across all its price lists. Price and speed always come from one option the company actually sells; every pair is scored and the pair with the most points stays. If two pairs tie, the cheaper one stays.
A company that never ties a price to a speed is scored on its lowest price at its standard speed.
A range of times is read at its slower end. Where a company gives a standard time and a maximum, the standard time is scored and the maximum shown.
Credits, tokens and packs that anyone can buy are priced at the lowest per-check rate the company publishes; the dollar figure is this guide’s arithmetic and is labelled as worked out. Membership, business and volume prices or speeds, options a page lists but does not let a customer choose, and price lists for other kinds of item are left out for every company.
The ends of each scale
Price and turnaround are placed between the cheapest and dearest, and the fastest and slowest, option in the table, counting every option of every scored service. So a change at either end moves every service’s score.
- Price: all 75 points at $2.85, set by CheckCheck (Sneakers 30 min); zero at $100, set by LegitCheck.app (Authentication Service: shoes $100.00).
- Turnaround: all 10 points at 10 min, set by LegitApp (Sneaker 10 Minutes); zero at 1 day, set by CheckCheck (Luxury Sneakers 24 hours).
- Brand count: all 2.5 points at 600 brands, LegitGrails.
Certificate
Issued with every check at no separate fee: 7.5 points. Sold as a paid add-on: 3.5 points, 7/15 of the certificate points (the share a paid certificate has held since this criterion was worth 15), rounded to two decimals. None, or nothing published about one: 0. Where a company never writes “free”, the page says it is included with no separate fee.
Verdict transparency
Each of these three earns 1.67 (5 ÷ 3) points, and only for a sentence the company publishes itself. That sentence is printed in the service’s entry with its page and the date it was read. Points go only to sentences printed here in the company’s own words; a summary written by this guide scores nothing.
An explanation given for one outcome only, such as a fake result, still counts as explained. An explanation sold as a paid extra does not.
- States that people examine or decide the item.
- States what part AI or other technology plays.
- States that you receive the reasons for the verdict.
The tag for who decides the verdict
Each service gets one tag, read only from the sentences credited above. The tag is shown and never scored. The tag human only is used only when the company’s own words say no AI is involved.
- human-led decision
- human only
- people examine the item; no technology statement published
- human, with technology; AI role not published
- human, AI pre-screen
- AI + human
- AI verdict
- not stated
Brand count
The number of brands the company says it checks for shoes, where it publishes one. Where it does not, its count across everything it checks is used, and the entry says so. The company’s own website is read before an app store listing, and where it gives more than one figure the lowest is used. A list of names is not a count.
2.5 × that count ÷ the largest count in the table. The scale starts at zero, so half the top count earns half the points.
Rounding
Points for each criterion are kept to two decimals out of 100, and those rounded figures are added up, so the breakdown below adds up to the total exactly. On the 10-point scale that is three decimals per criterion.
One ranking for the whole guide
Every page shows the same shoe ranking with the same totals. What a service publishes about one brand, a brand price or a brand list, appears on that brand’s page as a fact and moves no score.
Shown but not scored
- Guarantees and refund terms, printed as published, because they cannot be compared as one number.
- Accuracy figures and dispute wording, the companies’ own claims as published.
- Speeds sold only to members of a paid plan or to business accounts.
Dates
The rules were first written down on Sep 22, 2026; the weights last changed on Nov 16, 2026. The facts on this guide were read on the companies’ own pages, and each carries its own read date where it is printed.
Every score, criterion by criterion
Points on the 10-point scale: each criterion’s 100-point figure divided by ten. The five add up to the exact total, which is then rounded for display.
| # | Service | Price of 7.5 | Speed of 1 | Certificate of 0.75 | Verdict transparency of 0.5 | Brand count of 0.25 | Sum exact | Shown of 10 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | CheckCheck | 7.500 | 0.986 | 0.750 | 0.500 | 0.152 | 9.888 | 9.9 |
| 2 | LegitApp | 7.488 | 0.986 | 0.750 | 0.500 | 0.125 | 9.849 | 9.8 |
| 3 | LegitGrails | 7.257 | 0.923 | 0.750 | 0.500 | 0.250 | 9.680 | 9.7 |
| 4 | Legitmark | 6.948 | 0.881 | 0.750 | 0.500 | 0.038 | 9.117 | 9.1 |
| 5 | LegitCheck.app | 6.176 | 0.986 | 0.350 | 0.500 | 0.000 | 8.012 | 8.0 |
The price and speed each service was scored on
- CheckCheck publishes 5 price and speed pairs for shoes. The pair that earns the most points under this site’s method is $2.85 for 30 min on its Sneakers price list (3 credits at $0.95 each, bought as a 100-credit pack). The company prices this in units, so the dollar figure is worked out here as 3 credits × $0.95, shown to the cent as $2.85.
- LegitApp publishes 6 price and speed pairs for shoes. The pair that earns the most points under this site’s method is $3.00 for 30 min on its Sneaker Authentication price list (3 tokens at $1.00 each, bought as a 40-token pack). The company prices this in units, so the dollar figure is worked out here as 3 tokens × $0.99975, shown to the cent as $3.00.
- LegitGrails publishes 32 price and speed pairs for shoes. The pair that earns the most points under this site’s method is $6 for 2 h on its Air Jordan price list.
- Legitmark publishes 1 price and speed pair for shoes. The pair that earns the most points under this site’s method is $10 for 3 h on its Footwear price list.
- LegitCheck.app publishes 3 price and speed pairs for shoes. The pair that earns the most points under this site’s method is $20 for 30 min on its Authentication Service: shoes price list.
Change log
Every change to the rules, newest first. Two changes on one day are listed in the order they were made, the later one first.
-
New weights for shoes: price carries 75 of the 100 points. The rest go to turnaround (10), certificate (7.5), verdict transparency (5) and brand count (2.5). The same weights apply to every service in the table. Why: For lower-priced sneaker checks, the price you pay for one pair is given the most weight in the published method. Effect on this ranking: On Nov 16, 2026, CheckCheck went from second to first, LegitApp went from third to second and LegitGrails went from first to third.
-
A company’s own statement about the part technology plays in its verdict is now printed and scored whenever it meets the verdict-transparency rule: word for word, with its page and the date it was read, in that company’s entry. Why: A re-read found an eligible technology statement that had been recorded but not printed. Leaving it out meant the rule as applied differed from the rule as written. Effect on this ranking: On Nov 16, 2026, LegitGrails went from third to first, CheckCheck went from first to second and LegitApp went from second to third.
-
Every company’s pages were read again and one written rule set now applies to every company. Verdict transparency counts only sentences a company publishes that this guide prints beside it with the page and the date; a summary written here scores no points. Every price list a company publishes for shoes counts, not one chosen for it. Membership, business and volume prices are left out for everyone, and credits, tokens and packs anyone can buy are priced at the lowest per-check rate. A range of times counts at its slower end, and a stated standard time counts ahead of a stated maximum. Under the weights then in force, a certificate issued with every check at no separate fee got 16.5 points, a paid add-on 7.7, none 0. Only services that take new customers and publish a price for an online, photo-based check are scored; the rest are listed with the reason. The brand count is the company’s count for shoes where it gives one, otherwise its count across everything it checks, read from its own website first. Why: A review found the rules had been applied unevenly, in LegitGrails’ favour: its verdict wording was read from several pages while others were read from one sentence or from this guide’s own summary, its price came from a list picked for it, and some figures for other companies were out of date. Effect on this ranking: On Oct 1, 2026, CheckCheck went from third to first and LegitGrails went from first to third.
-
Brand pages stopped ranking on their own. Each now shows the home page order with the same totals; a price a company sets for one brand, and whether its brand list names that brand, sit beside the ranking as facts and feed no score. Why: One site, one ranking: before this, a service could be first on the home page and second on a brand page under the same weights.
-
Reviewer depth, the number of people who look at each pair, stopped counting, and so did the second-review element of verdict transparency. Its 10 points were shared out over what remained: 27.5 for price, 27.5 for turnaround, 16.5 for certificate, 16.5 for verdict transparency and 12 for brand count. Those weights held until Nov 16, 2026. Why: A headcount says how a company staffs its checks, not how many people will look at your pair. Some companies publish a minimum, some an upper limit, some a team size and some nothing, so the criterion was marking how each one describes its staff. Effect on this ranking: On Sep 23, 2026, LegitGrails went from second to first.
-
The rules were first written down as one method, with price and turnaround always taken from the same option a company sells.